Can Cupcake Recipes Be Doubled? (Answered)

It might be cliche to describe baking as a science, but it’s a cliche because it’s true. Making changes to a baking recipe, even if it’s small, can have a major impact on how a recipe turns out. When it comes to cupcakes, can cupcake recipes be doubled without ruining the final product?

Doubling a cupcake recipe has some risks, especially if you double a recipe within one bowl. It’s possible that you could end up with mixed results depending on the specific recipe you’re using. The more you alter a recipe, the farther away you might get from your desired finished product. 

If you need to make more than a single batch of cupcakes, there are ways to do so and save time without potentially ruining your cupcakes. 

Can You Double a Cupcake Recipe?

You technically can, but the issue with doubling a cupcake recipe is that the more ingredients you add to a mixing bowl, the more your cupcakes could end up changing in consistency and flavor. You also have to put in a lot more elbow grease to incorporate all the ingredients and you could end up overmixing your batter. 

You’re better off making two separate batches in two separate mixing bowls to make sure you get the exact finished product you want. 

Factors To Consider When Doubling Cupcake Recipes

If you want to attempt to double your cupcake recipe, there are some important factors to consider before you start sorting out your ingredients. 

Ingredient Proportions

Doubling a baking recipe requires more forethought than just simply adding two of everything to your batter. Some calculations are required to get proportions correct. 

Baking Time and Temperature

The more you pack up your oven with things to bake, the harder your oven is going to have to work. You can’t just pump up the oven temperature either, as you risk an uneven bake or even a burnt batch of cupcakes. 

Pan Size

You’ll have to make sure you’re using the same size cupcake pans for both batches of cupcakes. Otherwise, you’ll also have to adjust your baking time. You won’t end up with an even bake for both batches if any of your measurements are off. 

Oven Capacity

If you have a small oven, trying to bake two batches of cupcakes at once may not be possible. There needs to be space left in your oven for the hot air to circulate and make its way through every inch of your cupcake batter. 

Pros and Cons of Doubling Cupcake Recipes

Sometimes you might need more cupcakes than a single batch of a recipe can provide for you. As such, you’ll need to weigh the pros and cons of doubling up a recipe so you can decide your approach to baking as many cupcakes as you need. 

Advantages

Making two batches of cupcakes rather than doing one batch at a time can have its advantages. These advantages are only worth it, however, if you double up your recipe the right way. 

Time-Saving

Of course, the biggest draw towards doubling up cupcake recipes is saving time. Baking can take a lot of time and you need that time to ensure your cupcakes turn out well. Being able to bake two batches of cupcakes at the same time is a big advantage when you’re in a time crunch. 

Click Image for More Info

Convenient for Large Gatherings 

Making a lot of cupcakes for a special event or large gathering can take an entire day if you can’t find some time-saving measures. If you’re responsible for making cupcakes on your own, being able to make two batches at the same time makes this a much more bearable task. 

Disadvantages

The disadvantages of doubling cupcake recipes outweigh the benefits. While it seems time-saving and convenient, a ruined double batch of cupcakes means you’ll have to go back and start over. 

Possibility of Overbaking

You’ll have to watch a double batch of cupcakes very carefully since two batches of cupcakes will need to bake for a little bit longer due to heat distribution. 

Increased Risk of Inconsistency

The slightest change in your measurement of ingredients can make a big difference in how your cupcakes turn out. The risk gets bigger if you don’t make the right adjustments to simply double up a recipe in one bowl. It can’t be overstated how much easier it is to just make two batters in two separate bowls. 

Each bowl of cupcake batter needs to have the exact same amount of ingredients. You also need to make sure that your scoops of batter are the same measurement when pouring into each cupcake tin. 

What Adjustments Should You Keep In Mind When Doubling a Recipe?

Cupcakes made from scratch will most often have baking powder and baking soda in the recipe. You’ll have to do some math to determine how to adjust your baking powder and soda, as you don’t want to add two times the amount the recipe calls for. These two ingredients need to be reduced by one eighth of a teaspoon per teaspoon in the recipe as you double up. 

Can All Recipes Be Scaled Up and Down?

Baking recipes are too exact in terms of ingredient proportions to simply be scaled up or down. You have to break down each ingredient and determine the proper way to increase your final yield of batter. 

Final Thoughts 

If you need to bake a lot of cupcakes, the easiest way to make sure you get the desired results without a bunch of extra work is to make two batches of your batter in two separate containers. This way, you don’t have to do all the math associated with doubling up a recipe. 

There are times where you’re going to want a lot more than 12 cupcakes, so knowing the right way to go about preparing a bunch of cupcakes that turn out moist and delicious every time is a bit of a science. Thankfully, there are some known shortcuts that will help you bake double the amount of cupcakes without the headache of calculations and substitutes. Happy baking!

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *